AWN vs Cairo Dock vs Docky: Mac Style Linux Docks Reviewed

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (3 votes, average: 4.00 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

Mac style docks or launchers have become very popular among *nix users with the increase in popularity of Macs. And unlike Snow Leopard users there are quite a few free options for Linux users. I am going to review three such popular docks. The platform that i am using is Ubuntu 10.04 Lucid Lynx, but I would expect my conclusions to hold true for most of popular  *nix systems be it Fedora 13 or OpenSUSE 11.2.

Docky

Procedure to install Docky is standard, launch synaptic or corresponding Software Installer for your *nix, and search for and install docky. The standard installation of Docky looks something like this.

It is basically showing all the currently running applications. In addition you can choose to enable various “Docklets” (small dock applications, e.g. to display weather and time, mail box status etc.) by clicking on the “Anchor” icon and selecting Docklets tab as shown below or enable Helpers which are various application specific tools for more customized experience. It comes with 6 themes by default, and an option to enable 3D view. The icon animation effect is only limited to basic zoom functionality which you can configure to change the amount of zoom.

With the 3D background enabled and weather, Gmail, digital clock Docklets in action, it looks like this

Clicking the weather icon reduces the dock to detailed weather view in 2D with arrows to swtich between various weather details. Once you move your mouse away it resumes the default Dock view. Further by enabling Indicate Multiple Windows option in the setup, one can switch between different windows of the running application, e.g. choose between multiple open emacs frames or instances. However, Docky configuration doesn’t allow you to change the location or orientation of the Dock, but apparently you can change the location  when the config dialogue is open, you need to click on the dock and drag it to the required screen edge. The default position is bottom center.

AWN (Avant Window Navigator)

AWN in offers all the features that Docky has to offer, and a few more. Installation is again standard, search for avant-window-navigator in synaptic or do

sudo apt-get install avant-window-navigator

The dock as such as a more “finished” look to it in comparison to Docky. Multiple windows or instances of a particular applications are denoted by multiple triangles below the icon, you can also choose different sizes for icons. Clicking on an icon takes you directly to it, if only one instance is running, if there are multiple instances running then you are presented with the list of all the instances to choose from, which I thought is very well done.

The configuration can be done by clicking the first icon in the dock which is by default the AWN settings icon. AWN comes installed with 4 themes each of which is available in both 2D and 3D view, and you need to switch your view to 3D everytime you change your theme as switching themes automatically sets the 2D view.

AWN offers a wide range of applets just like Docky which can be activated from the Applets screen.

The weather applet has a nice curved display mode for forecasts which looks really cool.

While Docky only offers the standard zoom effect for the icons, AWN has as many as 10 (1 – custom) icon effects. The zoom effect is rather subtle for AWN and there is no option for changing the amount of zoom. I personally prefer the Squish effect and rotate effect.

Cairo Dock

Now lets look at the Cairo Dock. It clearly offers users with far more options than Docky and AWN put together.

It offers a simple configuration mode with less number of options (this less might be more than adequate for many).

Another mode is available for advanced configuration for those who want complete control. The discussion of all these options would have to be continued in another post. Cairo Dock also has a large collection of applets and comes installed with plenty of themes, modes, by default (by default I mean with the selection of most standard packages available for Cairo dock). Cairo dock also gives you the option to detach the applets and drop them on the desktop like widgets and you can choose to show your icons in 3D (e.g. in a elliptic cloud and other ways) . However, I also found Cairo dock to be less stable, e.g. when I tried to configure weather applet to make it display my local weather information, it crashed.

Bottomline: Docky is for all those who want simple and easy to use no hassle interface. AWN is probably a compromise between the two extremes, and Cairo Dock is for those who want total customization and complete control by getting your hands dirty. I personally like AWN the most simply because it strikes a good balance between customization and performance.

If you found this useful, please consider leaving a comment or liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

You might also like

Make Ubuntu 10.10 Maverick Look Like Mac (Snow Leopard) If you are...
Mac Style Dock for Ubuntu 9.10 or Ubuntu 10.04 You can have...
$26: Griffin PowerDock Dual-Position Charging Station for iPod and iPhone (Silver) Amazon offers...
Give Ubuntu Unity a Try (Install it in Ubuntu 10.10 Maverick) Unity is the...

About the Author

has written 1285 posts on this blog.

Meditating towards his "nerdvana", lifehacker is a teacher by the day and a nerdy blogger by the night. He lives to learn and yearns to learn living.

9 Comments on “AWN vs Cairo Dock vs Docky: Mac Style Linux Docks Reviewed”

  • revdjenk wrote on 26 June, 2010, 22:46

    Nice review…and I think you have them judged about right. I have used Docky early in its life, and have not tried it lately, but quickly went to AWN, but now use Cairo, exactly for its customization, and at the time, stability over the others.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0

    [Reply]

  • Mehdi wrote on 27 June, 2010, 6:24

    AWN when used along with DockbarX gave me the best experience.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    [Reply]

  • pouic wrote on 29 June, 2010, 11:34

    The conclusion is a bit hasty I think;
    Cairo-Dock is not only about options, but also the only one to have 3D effects and hardawre acceleration, as well as the ability to detach its applets on the desktop.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 3 Thumb down 0

    [Reply]

  • lifehacker wrote on 29 June, 2010, 12:19

    @pouic
    Capability to detach the applets and show icons in 3D are just more configuration options, which I should have mentioned, and I am updating my post to include it, thanks for pointing it out, but that doesn’t change the conclusion in any way. I also found Cairo dock to be less stable, e.g. when I tried to configure weather applet to make it display my local weather information. It crashed.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

    [Reply]

  • Zemblan wrote on 4 July, 2010, 17:10

    Contrary to what you say it is possible to reposition docky to other screen edges. When the congig dialogue is open click on the dock and drag it to the required screen edge.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 1

    [Reply]

  • lifehacker wrote on 5 July, 2010, 19:11

    @Zemblan
    Thanks for the info. Would update the post for the same.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 1

    [Reply]

  • mrblue wrote on 12 August, 2010, 5:40

    Docks are really cool and they are helpful when come to use.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 1

    [Reply]

Trackbacks

  1. Make Ubuntu 10.10 Maverick Look Like Mac (Snow Leopard) | Hack Your Life!
  2. AWN vs Cairo dock vs Docky | bilif

Write a Comment

Gravatars are small images that can show your personality. You can get your gravatar for free today!

*

Copyright © 2013 Hack Your Life!. All rights reserved.
Proudly powered by WordPress. Developed by Deluxe Themes